There is a lot of talk and much opinion around this subject and the following is as we see it, it is a changing situation and we do not claim to be experts!
So, what can you have in terms of "green", sustainable, environmentally friendly label stock?
The first question to ask, "what am I wanting to achieve?" It could be viewed that changing to a thinner PP material is better than a stnadard paper product, as the water and chemical use in production is less for some PP materials than paper, you may wish to consider the compostable nature of your "plastic" containers and use a suitable compostable label material / adhesive.
- We stock a semi-gloss paper with a permanent compostable* adhesive, some semi-gloss face produced from 15%* post consumer recycled fibre and a small amount of "grass" paper. However there are many other options available, we currently have samples out for approval of a compostable clear PE, so please do ask.
We are working towards all of our standard semi gloss paper being produced from recycled content during the later part of 2023.
(* it is also possible to get 100% post consumer recycled semi gloss)
We are able to supply a semi-transparent non-coated paper. TÜV AUSTRIA has certified this material for OK Compost Industrial, EN 13432, and OK Compost Home, and could be used to replace PP for use as a "clear seal" - See more below -
What will the cost implications be?
- Currently, the compostable adhesive options are around 3 - 4 times the cost, (raw material) while some of the recycled options are little different to more standard options.
Can we get a recycled face paper with the compostable adhesive?
- Yes, we can supply both a vellum and semi gloss option. The MOQ`s currently (October 2022) are quite large, 1,000 - 2,000 sq mts, but we hope this will drop.
Recyling Labels / Product with label applied -
Until mid 2018, we had always worked on the basis that a small label on a product would be fine to place in the usual recycle stream, a cardboard box with a paper label fine to place in your normal board/paper recycling. During the later part of 2018 and into 2019, the information around this seemed to be changing, indeed being told that if a product had a label stuck to it, this label should be removed before any recycling. This "news" inline with the ripples from the Blue Planet television program and also around the time that suppliers of our raw material were advising of better, more environmentally friendly materials coming to market.
The issue with a paper label is the adhesive, the paper not an issue, as soon as the adhesive is applied, seemingly we have a none recyclable product, or do we?
We spotted a news article that made us question the change in advice around recycling of standard products - Waitrose Egg Box / Packaging News Article
On the face of this, the statement "With the new label, the entire box supports a circular economy as it now uses recycled materials and is recyclable." would seem to be misleading, and so we sought some clarification.
There is a test/certification, INGEDE (11 & 12), which means that certain adhesives, (some of the certified/approved adhesives are ones we carry as stock items) are suitable to be recycled, IF the label does not cover more than 60% of the product in the case of paper/board. In synthetic materials, PP, PE, etc, this is 20%, while the label and bottle should be of the same material, ie a PP label on a PP bottle.
You can read more on the INGEDE tests here, although we warn that you may need a degree to understand.
The main drivers behind the demand and changes will be the supermarkets, and we hear differing stories of their views, some say that compostable product is what they ask for, others that they are asking for product to be made from post consumer recycled products. There does not seem to be an easy answer, we are not BRC approved so not party to any information they may circulate on the subject, but we do note that for instance that there is a common drive to become plastic free by 2023, with Iceland seeming to be making some good changes - see more.
We will try and offer alternatives where possible, we committed to the purchase of an amount of semi gloss with a compostable adhesive early in 2019, so we could sample and be ready to supply, and we are pleased to report that we do have some cuctomers taking this option now. We also have an amount of recycled product which we are using where suitable. We will do our utmost to offer these alternatives, but also understand that for some, the extra "cost" could be an issue.
It is fair to say that during early 2020, while a Global Pandemic had our attention, the requests for sustainable / environmentally friendly product had fallen away, equally true that since late July we are seeing more requests around what we can offer, we will do our best to advise the options as best we can and try to offer the sustainable and more environmentally friendly products where suitable.
You and view our own Environmental Policy and our Sustainable Procurement Policy in the Polices section at the bottom of the home page.
The following are links to some of our suppliers Sustainability / Recycling / Environmental pages -
* Until early 2023, the compostable adhesive options available where certified for industrial composting, in March of 2023 a new "home compostable" adhesive was made available - at the time of posting we are awaiting price / moq.